Summary2: Hide help text icon from Header component

[omtvad]

Description

This issue is related to the following already closed issue: #3749 (comment)

We would like a feature to hide the help icon related to Header component on the Summary2 page. Maybe an option to toggle it to be enabled/disabled would be a good solution?

Already we have looked into using the Paragraph component, but it does not allow to include the Help text icon and help text. Therefore, the Header component is the only right fit for us.

The attached screenshot illustrates the issue on Summary2.

Additional Information

[olemartinorg]

@omtvad I don't see any fundamental differences from the last (closed) issue. I'm still a bit puzzled about the reasoning behind this - what's the use-case where you want a help text, but you don't want to show it in Summary2? I.e., what is it with this help text that makes it no longer useful in a summary? What are your requirements for this form that makes this help text a problem here? Is it a matter of taste? Does it make the UI feel cluttered? Please, help me understand this.

While we could spend our days implementing all the features requested by everyone, we'll also just end up making a product that feels like it's been made as a compilation of everyones requests. This request isn't "a step too far" in any way, but since I genuinely don't see in which setting this is a requirement, I assume there's something deeper going on here about how we handle these texts than what the simple feature request is letting on.

[omtvad]

I see. I created this brand new issue due to the other being already closed.

This is more just about the matter of taste and a "nice to have". Visually it does not look perfect to us. Help text is shown in a strange context. The only case where Header with help text looks weird in Summary2 is when it is applied in the last section of the sub form, for us called "Notesider". When applied to other parts of the form the header in Summary2 looks just fine.

Header with help text works well in regards to the use of screen readers and meets all UU requirements.

You can safely skip this issue to prioritize others if that is what you feel like doing.

[olemartinorg]

I see!

The only case where Header with help text looks weird in Summary2 is when it is applied in the last section of the sub form, for us called "Notesider". When applied to other parts of the form the header in Summary2 looks just fine.

Which app is this, and how can we reproduce this issue to have a look ourselves? We might want to run this by our UX designers to see how best to solve this issue.

[omtvad]

The app is called Årsegnskap RR0002 - https://brg.apps.tt02.altinn.no/brg/aarsregnskap-vanlig-202406/ .

The issue can be reproduced by the following steps:

1. Navigate to the app
2. Sign in using the following test data:
   Fnr.: 27887197739
   Name: AKROBATISK POSSESSIV TIGER AS
   Gluten Flat for Maritim Uklar Tiger AS
3. Fill in mandatory information on pages Generell informasjon 1 & 2 (marked with an asterisk).
4. Fill in mandatory information in section Regnskapsskjema - Årsresultat, Eiendeler, Egenkapital & Gjeld.
5. Head to page Noter > Ekstraordinære inntekter og kostnader, and fill in some numbers for Ekstraordinære inntekter (as shown in the attached screenshot) and click Fullfør regnskapsskjema/ Tilbake til hovedskjema.
6. Upload a valid attachment on page Vedlegg and click Neste.
7. You will see that only Headers with help text belonging to section Noter will look different.

[RonnyB71]

You will see that only Headers with help text belonging to section Noter will look different

It looks different because it's one of the few headers with a help text. If you provide values in other sections where the header has a help text the icon will show there as well.

That said, I see that we don't show the help icon on the summary page for other components, only the headers. I'm not sure why, but like Ole Martin said, we'll have a chat with UX.