Determine overlaps with OBO

[cmungall]

1. Figure out how much overlap there is between CCO and OBO (either OBO-Core or specific domain ontologies)
2. Come up with a strategy: equivalence axioms vs ceding by one side

• CORE: only matches I see are document & plan
• ENVO: Align to CCO geospatial entities EnvironmentOntology/envo#625

[cmungall]

following are automated and include obvious false positives

IAO

IAO	IAO label	CCO	CCO label
IAO:0000013	journal article	CCO:JournalArticle	Journal Article
IAO:0000030	information content entity	CCO:InformationContentEntity	Information Content Entity
IAO:0000064	algorithm	CCO:Algorithm	Algorithm
IAO:0000088	report	CCO:Report	Report
IAO:0000101	image	CCO:Image	Image
IAO:0000112	example of usage	CCO:example_of_usage	example of usage
IAO:0000115	definition	CCO:definition	definition
IAO:0000117	term editor	CCO:term_editor	term editor
IAO:0000119	definition source	CCO:definition_source	definition source
IAO:0000132	lot number	CCO:LotNumber	Lot Number
IAO:0000136	is about	CCO:ModalRelationOntology/is_about	is about
IAO:0000136	is about	CCO:is_about	is about
IAO:0000310	document	CCO:Document	Document
IAO:0000600	elucidation	CCO:elucidation	elucidation

OBI

OBI	OBI label	CCO	CCO Label
OBI:0000245	organization	CCO:Organization	Organization
OBI:0000260	plan	CCO:PlanSpecification	Plan
OBI:0000753	Waters	CHEBI:15377	water
OBI:0000844	hospital	CCO:Hospital	Hospital
OBI:0000940	optical microscope	CCO:OpticalMicroscope	Optical Microscope
OBI:0000967	container	CCO:Container	Container
OBI:0000990	electron microscope	CCO:ElectronMicroscope	Electron Microscope
OBI:0400022	Cyan	CCO:Cyan	Cyan
OBI:0400064	laser	CCO:Laser	Laser
OBI:0400107	computer	CCO:Computer	Computer
OBI:0400169	microscope	CCO:Microscope	Microscope

PATO

CCO	CCO Label	OBO	OBO label
CCO:Acceleration	Acceleration	PATO:0001028	acceleration
CCO:Albedo	Albedo	PATO:0001295	albedo
CCO:Amount	Amount	PATO:0000070	amount
CCO:Amplitude	Amplitude	PATO:0000080	amplitude
CCO:AngularVelocity	Angular Velocity	PATO:0001413	angular velocity
CCO:Bent	Bent	PATO:0000617	bent
CCO:BiologicalSex	Biological Sex	PATO:0000047	biological sex
CCO:Black	Black	PATO:0000317	black
CCO:Blond	Blond	PATO:0001264	light yellow
CCO:Blue	Blue	PATO:0000318	blue
CCO:Blunt	Blunt	PATO:0001950	blunt
CCO:Bow	Bow	PATO:0000406	curved
CCO:Branched	Branched	PATO:0000402	branched
CCO:Brown	Brown	PATO:0000952	brown
CCO:Circumference	Circumference	PATO:0001648	circumference
CCO:Closure	Closure	PATO:0000136	closure
CCO:Coiled	Coiled	PATO:0000404	coiled
CCO:Color	Color	PATO:0000014	color
CCO:ColorBrightness	Color Brightness	PATO:0000016	color brightness
CCO:ColorHue	Color Hue	PATO:0000015	color hue
CCO:ColorSaturation	Color Saturation	PATO:0000017	color saturation
CCO:Combustion	Combustion	PATO:0015021	combustibility
CCO:Cuboidal	Cuboidal	PATO:0001872	cuboid
CCO:Cyan	Cyan	PATO:0000319	cyan
CCO:Cylindrical	Cylindrical	PATO:0001873	cylindrical
CCO:Density	Mass Density	PATO:0001019	mass density
CCO:Depth	Depth	PATO:0001595	depth
CCO:Diameter	Diameter	PATO:0001334	diameter
CCO:Drooping	Drooping	PATO:0002165	drooping
CCO:Fatigability	Fatigability	PATO:0001815	fatigability
CCO:Flat	Flat	PATO:0000407	flat
CCO:Fluorescence	Fluorescence	PATO:0000018	fluorescence
CCO:Folded	Folded	PATO:0001910	folded
CCO:Force	Force	PATO:0001035	force
CCO:Frequency	Frequency	PATO:0000044	frequency
CCO:Green	Green	PATO:0000320	green
CCO:Grey	Grey	PATO:0000950	grey
CCO:Hardness	Hardness	PATO:0000048	hardness
CCO:Height	Height	PATO:0000119	height
CCO:HighFrequency	High Frequency	PATO:0000380	increased frequency
CCO:Initialism	Initialism	PATO:0002325	onset quality
CCO:Length	Length	PATO:0000122	length
CCO:Loudness	Loudness	PATO:0001521	sound amplitude
CCO:LowFrequency	Low Frequency	PATO:0000381	decreased frequency
CCO:Magenta	Magenta	PATO:0000321	magenta
CCO:Magnetic	Magnetism	PATO:0001682	magnetism
CCO:Maroon	Maroon	PATO:0001426	maroon
CCO:Mass	Mass	PATO:0000125	mass
CCO:ModalRelationOntology/asWKT	as WKT	http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql#asWKT	as WKT
CCO:ModalRelationOntology/has_part	has_part	BFO:0000051	has_part
CCO:ModalRelationOntology/part_of	part_of	BFO:0000050	part_of
CCO:ModalRelationOntology/precedes	precedes	PATO:0001632	anterior to
CCO:Momentum	Momentum	PATO:0001023	momentum
CCO:Oblong	Oblong	PATO:0000946	oblong
CCO:Opacity	Opacity	PATO:0000957	opacity
CCO:Opaque	Opaque	PATO:0000963	opaque
CCO:Orange	Orange	PATO:0000953	orange
CCO:Organization	Organization	PATO:0000938	organized
CCO:Perimeter	Perimeter	PATO:0001711	perimeter
CCO:Phosphorescence	Phosphorescence	PATO:0001298	phosphorescence
CCO:Power	Power	PATO:0001024	power
CCO:Pressure	Pressure	PATO:0001025	pressure
CCO:Protruding	Protruding	PATO:0001598	protruding
CCO:Purple	Purple	PATO:0000951	purple
CCO:Pyramidal	Pyramidal	PATO:0002336	pyramidal
CCO:Radioactive	Radioactive	PATO:0001740	activity (of a radionuclide)
CCO:Radiopacity	Radiopacity	PATO:0002136	radiopacity
CCO:Radiopaque	Radiopaque	PATO:0002137	radiopaque
CCO:Rectangular	Rectangular	PATO:0001867	rectangular
CCO:Red	Red	PATO:0000322	red
CCO:Refractivity	Refractivity	PATO:0001372	refractivity
CCO:Rosy	Rosy	PATO:0001425	rosy
CCO:Round	Round	PATO:0000411	circular
CCO:Scar	Scar	PATO:0001850	scarred
CCO:Semicircular	Semicircular	PATO:0002232	semicircular
CCO:Serrated	Serrated	PATO:0001206	serrated
CCO:Sharp	Sharp	PATO:0000944	sharpness
CCO:Sloped	Sloped	PATO:0001481	sloped
CCO:SoundFrequency	Sound Frequency	PATO:0001520	sound frequency
CCO:SoundWavelength	Sound Wavelength	PATO:0001523	sound wavelength
CCO:Speed	Speed	PATO:0000008	speed
CCO:Spherical	Spherical	PATO:0001499	spherical
CCO:Split	Split	PATO:0001444	broken
CCO:Square	Square	PATO:0000413	square
CCO:Straight	Straight	PATO:0002180	straight
CCO:Strength	Strength	PATO:0001230	strength
CCO:SurfaceTension	Surface Tension	PATO:0001461	surface tension
CCO:Telescope	Telescope	PATO:0002313	telescopic
CCO:Temperature	Temperature	PATO:0000146	temperature
CCO:Texture	Texture	PATO:0000150	texture
CCO:Thickness	Thickness	PATO:0000591	increased thickness
CCO:Thin	Thin	PATO:0000592	decreased thickness
CCO:Translucent	Translucent	PATO:0001354	translucent
CCO:Transparent	Transparent	PATO:0000964	transparent
CCO:Triangular	Triangular	PATO:0001875	triangular
CCO:Tripod	Tripod	PATO:0002428	tripodal
CCO:Velocity	Velocity	PATO:0002242	velocity
CCO:Vermilion	Vermilion	PATO:0001302	vermilion
CCO:Violet	Violet	PATO:0001424	violet
CCO:Wavelength	Wavelength	PATO:0001242	wavelength
CCO:Wavy	Wavy	PATO:0000967	undulate
CCO:Weight	Weight	PATO:0000128	weight
CCO:Wetness	Wetness	PATO:0001822	wetness
CCO:White	White	PATO:0000323	white
CCO:Wide	Wide	PATO:0000600	increased width
CCO:Width	Width	PATO:0000921	width
CCO:Yellow	Yellow	PATO:0000324	yellow
CCO:definition	definition	IAO:0000115	definition

ENVO

ENVO	ENVO label	CCO	CCO label
ENVO:00000000	geographic feature	CCO:GeographicFeature	Geographic Feature
ENVO:00000005	first-order administrative region	CCO:FirstOrderAdministrativeRegion	First-Order Administrative Region
ENVO:00000006	second-order administrative region	CCO:SecondOrderAdministrativeRegion	Second-Order Administrative Region
ENVO:00000007	third-order administrative region	CCO:ThirdOrderAdministrativeRegion	Third-Order Administrative Region
ENVO:00000008	fourth-order administrative region	CCO:FourthOrderAdministrativeRegion	Fourth-Order Administrative Region
ENVO:00000009	national geopolitical entity	CCO:Country	Country
ENVO:00000011	garden	CCO:Park	Park
ENVO:00000012	hydrographic feature	CCO:HydrographicFeature	Hydrographic Feature
ENVO:00000014	canal	CCO:Canal	Canal
ENVO:00000025	reservoir	CCO:Reservoir	Reservoir
ENVO:00000029	watercourse	CCO:Branched	Branched
ENVO:00000040	waterfall	CCO:Force	Force
ENVO:00000062	populated place	CCO:PopulatedPlace	Populated place
ENVO:00000064	road	CCO:Highway	Highway
ENVO:00000065	railway	CCO:Railway	Railway
ENVO:00000066	man-made tunnel	CCO:Tunnel	Tunnel
ENVO:00000070	construction	CCO:ConstructedFeature	Constructed Feature
ENVO:00000074	dam	CCO:Dam	Dam
ENVO:00000075	bridge	CCO:Bridge	Bridge
ENVO:00000076	mine	CCO:Mine	Mine
ENVO:00000077	agricultural feature	CCO:AgriculturalFacility	Agricultural Facility
ENVO:00000078	farm	CCO:Farm	Farm
ENVO:00000087	cliff	CCO:Scar	Scar
ENVO:00000101	delta	CCO:Fan	Fan
ENVO:00000104	undersea feature	CCO:Flat	Flat
ENVO:00000122	track	CCO:Trail	Trail
ENVO:00000158	causeway	CCO:Road	Road
ENVO:00000191	solid astronomical body part	CCO:PhysiographicFeature	Physiographic Feature
ENVO:00000533	landfill	CCO:Landfill	Landfill
ENVO:00000563	pier	CCO:Pier	Pier
ENVO:00000856	city	CCO:City	City
ENVO:00002000	slope	CCO:Sloped	Sloped
ENVO:00002173	hospital	CCO:Hospital	Hospital
ENVO:00002221	shop	CCO:Shop	Shop
ENVO:00002271	nuclear power plant	CCO:NuclearPowerPlant	Nuclear Power Plant
ENVO:00002297	environmental feature	CCO:EnvironmentalFeature	Environmental Feature
ENVO:00002874	air conditioning unit	CCO:AirConditioningUnit	Air Conditioning Unit
ENVO:00003963	warehouse	CCO:Warehouse	Warehouse
ENVO:01000162	organ	CCO:Organization	Organization
ENVO:01000417	house	CCO:House	House
ENVO:01000460	asphalt	CCO:Pitch	Pitch
ENVO:01000536	factory	CCO:Factory	Factory
ENVO:01000577	radio device	CCO:RadioReceiver	Radio Receiver
ENVO:01000580	telephone	CCO:Telephone	Telephone
ENVO:01000582	landline telephone	CCO:LandlineTelephone	Landline Telephone
ENVO:01000602	truck	CCO:Truck	Truck
ENVO:01000604	vehicle	CCO:Vehicle	Vehicle
ENVO:01000610	motor	CCO:Engine	Engine
ENVO:01000611	bus	CCO:Bus	Bus
ENVO:01000613	watercraft	CCO:Watercraft	Watercraft
ENVO:01000614	bicycle	CCO:Bicycle	Bicycle
ENVO:01000615	motorcycle	CCO:Motorcycle	Motorcycle
ENVO:01000733	stock	CCO:Stock	Stock
ENVO:01000773	village	CCO:Village	Village
ENVO:01000779	public infrastructure	CCO:Infrastructure	Infrastructure
ENVO:01000984	grocery store	CCO:GroceryStore	Grocery Store
ENVO:01001221	office building	CCO:OfficeBuilding	Office Building
ENVO:01001488	aircraft	CCO:Aircraft	Aircraft
ENVO:2000037	fossil fuel power plant	CCO:FossilFuelPowerPlant	Fossil Fuel Power Plant

[robsyc]

Hello, I only recently found out about this project and I was wondering what the relation is between this and COB

The COB is still in development but I think the idea is also to provide a mid-level ontology for other domain-ontologies in OBO to find common ground with. Are there COO contributors who also work on COB or is this completely independent?

I think it could be a good place for OBO and CCO to find consensus.