Data Element Key of ISXD Data Elements

[czh0405]

Hi,
I try to use MXFInspect to inspect some MXF files. It works pretty great, and I Iattempted to analyze ISXD MXF files.
I reviewed SMPTE ST 2067-202:2023 and found ISXD Data Elements key is defined in SMPTE ST 2067-202:2023.

so I think the name of the key marked in the red box in the following figure is "Frame Wrapped ISXD Data", rather than "Privately Registered UL (Dolby Laboratories Inc.)"

Thanks in advance for your help, and congratulations for your great work!

[rayden84]

Thank you for opening this issue and helping make MXFInspect better.
At first glance the problem that you are describing can and should be resolved. Unfortunately I have never seen an ISXD MXF file, the name is pretty new to me...would you mind uploading a sample somehwere, so that I can have a look?
The issue here is surely related to NOTE 3 of the SMPTE document, so MXFInspect treats this element to be private as outlined below:

3.2.9 Class 14: Organizationally registered as private

Metadata in this class shall consist of individual elements or groups of elements of metadata that have been registered by a specific user organization or individual and are therefore reserved and managed separately from the other classes (1 -7) of metadata.

[czh0405]

I'm sorry, MXF upload is not supported here. Could you please provide an email address? I can send you the ISXD MXF sample.
and I uploaded the file : SMPTE ST 2067-202:2023.

st2067-202-2023.pdf

[rayden84]

Just upload here a sample:
https://1drv.ms/f/c/5115bdb352273e27/IgAaB2IIpUloTIgyRhn5USCNAdbJRiVtGfeJBraaB3XbjTs?e=8hc76V
Thank you

[czh0405]

The MXF sample has been uploaded.

[rayden84]

Please have a look at the following release and tell me if it handles the issue properly:
https://github.com/rayden84/MXFInspect/releases/tag/v4.3.1

Once I have your green light I will integrate the work done in my fork into this repo.

[czh0405]

https://github.com/rayden84/MXFInspect/releases/tag/v4.3.1， the url is not found，and I only find tag v4.3.0

[rayden84]

Sorry, try the link https://github.com/rayden84/MXFInspect/releases/tag/v4.3.1 again, I forgot to set it from draft to pre release.

[czh0405]

Thanks，I test v4.3.1 and it handles the issue properly.