Problem with the annotation of Piano Sonata n.30

[giamic]

Hi,
In the 1st movement of sonata n.30, I think that there is a small issue with the annotations. Bar 65 (counting the pickup measure as measure 0), the last one of the Adagio before Tempo I arrives again, has a duration of 5.5 quarter notes while in your annotations it is considered as 4 quarter notes. This is due to the sextuplets being considered as having each a duration of 0.5 quarters, while the score actually shows 1 quarter. I encountered this issue while trying to mix your functional harmony annotations with other analysis, which produced an error due to the mismatch in the total duration of the movement.

The score can be found at https://imslp.org/wiki/Piano_Sonata_No.30,_Op.109_(Beethoven,_Ludwig_van).

[Tsung-Ping]

Hi,

Sorry for the late reply. It might result from that we used different versions of the score.
See the one I used (score). The tonic chord actually has a duration of 4 quarter notes (3 + 1, from Bar 65 beat 1 to Bar 66 beat 2).

Note that the notations at Bar 65 have some problems: the tuplets should have three beams not two.