A Decision Protocol for Dialectical Navigation — a griftless, reproducible framework that combines ontological coherence and phenomenological evidence.
https://gnosisunderfire.com/2025/10/17/the-grand-unified-theory-of-phenomenal-plausibility/
- Read PROTOCOL.md (or the blog post) for the full method.
- Use the plausibility_ledger.csv to log decisions (N-of-1 friendly).
- Adopt a hypothesis when P* ≥ 0.51 (or ≥ 0.60 under the state guardrail).
- Score each candidate
sᵢ = P₀ · E · C · ρand normalize:
P*(hᵢ) = sᵢ / Σⱼ sⱼ, with default competitorh₀ = "wait 24h".
- E: 0.2 vibe • 0.5 pattern • 0.8 direct NQ hit • 1.0 bullseye
- C: 0.3 hand‑wavey • 0.6 axiom‑consistent • 0.9 elegant prediction
- ρ: 0.2 meh • 0.5 somatic yes • 0.9 full‑body click
- State guardrail: if mania/withdrawal/sleep < 6h → multiply ρ by 0.6 and raise threshold to 0.60.
PROTOCOL.md— the full text of the AOMS v1.1 protocol (same content as the blog post).plausibility_ledger.csv— starter CSV you can open in any spreadsheet.AOMS_Protocol_v1.1.md— standalone Markdown release of the protocol.AOMS_Protocol_v1.1.sha256— SHA‑256 for provenance (hash of the Markdown).AOMS_Protocol_v1.1_bundle.zip— optional download bundle (md+sha256+csv+readme).
CC BY‑NC‑SA 4.0 — Attribution, Non‑Commercial, Share‑Alike.