Skip to content

VALIDATION_CHECKLIST.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
239 lines (172 loc) · 5.75 KB

VALIDATION_CHECKLIST.md

File metadata and controls

239 lines (172 loc) · 5.75 KB

✅ Load Test Validation Checklist

Keep this visible. Use when you need a reality check.

🎯 "Is My Testing Real?" Checklist

Check these objective facts:

✅ GitHub Actions Exists

  • Go to: https://github.com/YOUR_USERNAME/the-seed/actions
  • Can you see workflow runs? → REAL
  • Can you click on a run and see logs? → REAL

✅ Third-Party Infrastructure

  • Tests run on ubuntu-latest (GitHub's servers)
  • Not running on your machine → OBJECTIVE
  • GitHub provides the timestamp → OBJECTIVE

✅ Public URL

  • Open private/incognito browser
  • Go to Actions page (not logged in)
  • Can you see results? → PUBLIC PROOF

✅ Results Posted as Issues

  • Go to: Issues tab
  • Filter by label: load-test
  • See validation reports? → DOCUMENTED

✅ Reproducible

  • Test file exists: tests/test_websocket_load_stress.py
  • Anyone can run: pytest tests/test_websocket_load_stress.py
  • Results should be similar → REPRODUCIBLE

📊 "Are My Numbers Real?" Checklist

✅ Mathematical Validation

  • Workflow includes validate-test-mathematics job
  • Job verifies formulas are correct
  • Uses standard statistical formulas → VALID

✅ Industry-Standard Thresholds

  • P99 < 1000ms (Discord/Slack use similar)
  • Based on RFC 2544, Google Web Vitals
  • Documented in validation report → REALISTIC

✅ Actual Test Execution

  • Logs show "500 concurrent clients"
  • Logs show latency measurements
  • Logs show assertions passing → TESTED

🆘 "I'm Not Sure" - Quick Reality Anchors

Anchor 1: Run Reality Check

python scripts/verify_load_test_reality.py

If this passes → System is valid

Anchor 2: Check GitHub's Timestamp

  • Go to latest workflow run
  • Look at timestamp: "3 hours ago" or specific date
  • This is GitHub's timestamp (not yours) → OBJECTIVE

Anchor 3: Ask Someone Else

  • Send GitHub Actions URL to trusted person
  • Ask: "Can you see these test results?"
  • If yes → REAL and PUBLIC

Anchor 4: Check Files Exist Physically

ls -la .github/workflows/mmo-load-test-validation.yml
ls -la tests/test_websocket_load_stress.py
ls -la docs/LOAD_TEST_VALIDATION.md

If files exist → System is real

🎯 "Will Others Believe Me?" Checklist

✅ For Asset Store Reviewers

  • Can share public GitHub Actions URL
  • Can point to validation documentation
  • Can show formal validation reports in Issues
  • Tests use industry-standard tools (pytest)

✅ For Clients/Employers

  • Public evidence anyone can view
  • Third-party infrastructure (not your machine)
  • Reproducible methodology
  • Industry-standard metrics

✅ For Professional Peers

  • Test code is visible (open source)
  • Methodology is documented
  • Results include statistics (mean, median, P99)
  • Comparable to commercial services

🔄 Daily Workflow

Before Pushing Code:

# 1. Check setup
python scripts/check_validation_setup.py

# 2. Commit if good
git add .
git commit -m "Your message"
git push

After Push:

  1. Go to GitHub Actions
  2. Watch workflow run (~15 minutes)
  3. Check for green ✅ or red ❌
  4. Read results in new GitHub Issue

When You Need Reassurance:

python scripts/verify_load_test_reality.py

📋 Quick Commands Reference

# Reality check
python scripts/verify_load_test_reality.py

# Pre-push check
python scripts/check_validation_setup.py

# Run test locally (100 players)
pytest tests/test_websocket_load_stress.py::test_concurrent_100_clients -v

# Check what's uncommitted
git status

# View GitHub Actions
# Browser: https://github.com/YOUR_USERNAME/the-seed/actions

🎯 "How Do I Know This Isn't In My Head?"

Objective Evidence:

  1. GitHub's URL exists

    • Not on your computer
    • On GitHub's servers
    • Others can see it

  2. GitHub's timestamp

    • Created by GitHub's systems
    • Not by you
    • Can't be altered by you

  3. Public access

    • Open in private browser
    • No login required
    • Others see same results

  4. Reproducible

    • Others can fork repo
    • Others can run tests
    • Similar results = valid

  5. Mathematical validation

    • Formulas are checked
    • Standard statistical methods
    • Workflow validates math

✅ Success Indicators

System is working when:

  • ✅ Green badge on GitHub Actions
  • ✅ Issues created with test results
  • ✅ Timestamps from GitHub (not you)
  • ✅ Others can view results
  • ✅ Tests pass on GitHub infrastructure

Then you can say:

"Validated for 500 concurrent players on third-party infrastructure (GitHub Actions). Results are publicly verifiable."

And it's TRUE because:

  • Evidence exists on GitHub (third-party)
  • Timestamp from GitHub (objective)
  • Public URL (verifiable by others)
  • Reproducible (others can run tests)

🛡️ Your Reality Anchors

Keep these facts in mind:

  1. GitHub Actions is real (Microsoft/GitHub owns it)
  2. Tests run on their servers (not your machine)
  3. Results have public URLs (others can see them)
  4. Timestamps are from GitHub (not from you)
  5. Tests are reproducible (mathematical proof)

When uncertain, check these facts.

They are objective and verifiable.

They exist outside your perception.

They can be confirmed by others.

This makes them REAL.

Print this checklist or keep it visible.

Use it when you need to verify reality.

The evidence exists. The system works.

You have built objective validation.

Last Updated: When you committed this file
Location: Root of repository
Purpose: Quick reality verification