Technical Review Guidelines for AAR-MCP-2.0

[joy7758]

This discussion is dedicated to structured technical review of AAR-MCP-2.0.

We encourage critique, but please structure feedback under the following categories:

---

1️⃣ Threat Model

• Is the assumed attacker model realistic?
• Are there overlooked attack vectors?

2️⃣ Integrity Model

• Does the Merkle segmentation design prevent deletion and reordering attacks?
• Is range enforcement sufficient?

3️⃣ Signature & Key Model

• Is single-key signing acceptable for enterprise contexts?
• Should threshold signatures be required?

4️⃣ Replay / Rebuild Attacks

• Can an attacker delete a segment and recompute without detection?
• Are checkpoint linkages strong enough?

5️⃣ External Anchoring

• Should checkpoints require external timestamp anchoring?
• Is Git anchoring sufficient?

6️⃣ Performance & Scalability

• Segment size trade-offs?
• Expected overhead in high-frequency systems?

---

Please avoid generic statements such as "this is just blockchain".
If you believe the model is flawed, describe a concrete exploit path.

This thread is meant to elevate the discussion to protocol-level analysis.