Skip to content

GAP_AUDIT.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
84 lines (70 loc) · 5.65 KB

GAP_AUDIT.md

File metadata and controls

84 lines (70 loc) · 5.65 KB

Codencer Gap Audit & Readiness

Warning

INTERNAL DEVELOPER DOCUMENT: This file is for project maintainers and contains technical debt audits, task backlogs, and roadmap tracking. For the official User Guide, please refer to the README.md.

Current Reality

  • Lifecycle Meaning Cleanup: [RESOLVED] Explicitly defined Run (Session), Step (Planner Unit), and Attempt (Execution Try) in domain code and README. Verified that no bridge-side decision logic is implied.
  • Terminology Inconsistency: [RESOLVED] Renamed all outcome indicators to State (RunState, StepState, Result.State) for uniform operator experience.
  • Ergonomics: [RESOLVED] Tightened the submit -> wait -> result sequence and established the Canonical Local Runbook in EXAMPLES.md.
  • Trust & Transparency: [RESOLVED] Added "Known Limitations" and clarified the distinction between simulation and real-mode execution in README.
  • Release Surface: [RESOLVED] Performed a unified v1 Truth-Pass across all README, setup, examples, and guide documentation.
  • OpenClaw Status: [ALIGNED] Maintained as Experimental Alpha-tier for v1.0. Future promotion to stable requires sustained user verification.

Feature Status Matrix

Component Status Implementation Type Notes
Orchestration Core ✅ Ready (Stable) Native (SQLite) Persistent ledger, state machine, and Git Worktrees.
CLI & MCP Layer ✅ Ready (Stable) Native Human-readable hints, logs, and structured JSON.
Codex Adapter ✅ Ready (Stable) CLI Wrapper High-fidelity relay with artifact harvesting.
OpenClaw Adapter 🧪 Experimental (Alpha) ACPX Wrapper Functional alpha; basic lifecycle tracking.
Claude Adapter 🟢 Supported (Beta) CLI Wrapper Uses claude -p --output-format json with stdin prompt delivery, cwd-based execution, synthesized result mapping, and fake-binary integration coverage. Live authenticated Claude service calls are not exercised in repo tests.
Qwen Adapter 🟡 Functional CLI Wrapper Basic subprocess wrapper; narrower evidence extraction than Codex/Claude.
Simulation Mode ✅ Ready (Stable) Native Robust stubs for orchestrator validation.
Adaptive Routing 🧪 Prototype Heuristic Static fallback chain; not yet benchmark-driven.
Governance ✅ Ready (Stable) Manual MIT Licensed; CONTRIBUTING.md authored.
Diagnostics ✅ Ready (Stable) CLI doctor command verifies versions and environment.

Known Technical Debt & Limitations

  • Adaptive Routing: Routing is currently based on a static heuristic chain; benchmark-driven optimization is documented but not dynamic.
  • Process Introspection: CLI-wrapped adapters provide limited visibility beyond standard streams.
  • Simulation Limits: Simulation Mode stubs all actions; it validates the orchestrator's state-machine but does not test real agent logic.

V1 Publication Audit (Phase V1.F3)

🚨 Critical Publication Blockers (Must Fix)

  1. LICENSE: ✅ RESOLVED (MIT).
  2. CONTRIBUTING.md: ✅ RESOLVED.
  3. Repository Noise: ✅ RESOLVED (codencer.db removed/ignored).
  4. Makefile Version: ✅ RESOLVED (v1.0-release-candidate).
  5. Setup Reproducibility: ✅ RESOLVED (make setup build verified).

🛡 Trust & Readability Gaps (Should Fix)

  1. Agent Versioning: doctor command detects binary existence but not version compatibility (e.g. codex-agent v0.5 vs v1.0).
  2. Internal Documentation Noise: ✅ RESOLVED (Upgraded headers and README navigation).
  3. Example Parity: Ensure examples/tasks/*.yaml are 100% compliant with the latest schema.

🛠 Ready for Release Finalization

  1. Governance: ✅ RESOLVED (MIT & CONTRIBUTING.md).
  2. Health: Enhance doctor with version checks for git and sqlite3.
  3. Documentation Quality Audit: ✅ PASS (Rendering issues fixed; Quickstart aligned).

V1 Publication Readiness Audit (Batch V1.F5)

🕹 Current First-Run Path

  1. make setup build: Creates directories and compiles binaries.
  2. cp .env.example .env: Manual configuration.
  3. make start-sim: Daemon starts in background.
  4. run start -> submit --wait: Primary operator loop.
  5. step result/logs/artifacts: Evidence inspection.

🏥 Diagnostics Capabilities

  • doctor: Verifies .codencer directory, daemon connectivity, and basic binary existence (PATH).
  • smoke: Exercises the basic relay loop in simulation mode.

🚨 Release Blockers (Must Fix)

  1. doctor Versioning: ✅ RESOLVED (Version checks for git, sqlite3, go, and codex-agent implemented).
  2. doctor Environment: ✅ RESOLVED (Checks for .env and directory structure implemented).
  3. Smoke Test Brittleness: ✅ RESOLVED (Modernized smoke_test.sh with JSON parsing and submit --wait).
  4. Port Conflict: ✅ RESOLVED (Standardized on 8080 in .env and smoke_test.sh).

🛠 Deployment/CI Hardening (Next Phase)

  1. Setup Logic: Improve make setup to safely handle .env initialization (Current: Manual cp).
  2. Binary Distribution: Move beyond go build to pre-compiled releases.
  • Audit Trust & Readiness Alignment (Final Alignment Complete)
  • V1 Publication Readiness Audit (Batch V1.F5 Complete)
  • Harden doctor with binary version checking (Batch V1.R1 Complete)
  • Align Smoke Test with modern CLI ergonomics (Batch V1.R1 Complete)
  • Batch R2: Final Metadata & Release Notes (Complete)
    • Update version strings to v1.0-release-candidate
    • Create CHANGELOG.md
    • Final Sanity Audit