Skip to content

Commit dcc1fbd

Browse files
plaidfinchclaude
andcommitted
Emphasize narrative flow over quote collection
Refine writing guidance to clarify that the goal is to educate through coherent narrative, not to compile disconnected quotes. Key changes: - Add "Overall Approach: Narrative, Not Vignettes" section up front - Emphasize the WHY, HOW, and WHAT NEXT structure - "Use quotes to illuminate, not to replace narrative" - Explicitly warn against "vignetted quotes" - Quotes should support and illuminate the explanation - Goal is fluid, conversational, educational writing Updated both the Usage Guidelines and Writing Style sections to reinforce this principle consistently. Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code) Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent 71242b2 commit dcc1fbd

File tree

1 file changed

+26
-8
lines changed

1 file changed

+26
-8
lines changed

.claude/skills/rfd-api/SKILL.md

Lines changed: 26 additions & 8 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -288,14 +288,15 @@ When using `--format json`, responses include structured data. Key fields in RFD
288288
2. **Use meta for quick lookups** when you just need basic info: `rfd-cli meta --number <N> --format json`
289289
3. **Use view for full content** when you need to read the actual document: `rfd-cli view --number <N> --format json`
290290
4. **Check discussion URLs** to find related GitHub PRs and conversations
291-
5. **Quote liberally from RFDs** to support your explanations:
292-
- Include direct quotes from RFDs to illustrate key points
293-
- Use block quotes (>) for longer passages that capture important context
294-
- Quote specific technical decisions, rationale, and determinations verbatim
295-
- Include memorable phrases that capture Oxide's engineering philosophy
296-
- Attribution is important: always cite the RFD number when quoting
297-
- Direct quotes make answers more authoritative and help users understand the source material
298-
6. **Summarize findings** for the user - but supplement summaries with direct quotes for key points
291+
5. **Use quotes to support narrative, not replace it**:
292+
- Build a coherent explanation first, then use quotes to illuminate key points
293+
- Quote passages that reveal reasoning, philosophy, or memorable articulations
294+
- Use block quotes (>) sparingly for particularly important passages
295+
- Weave shorter quotes inline to support points you're making
296+
- Always cite the RFD number when quoting
297+
- Avoid "quote vignettes" - disconnected quotations with minimal explanation
298+
- Your goal is to educate: explain the why, how, and what next
299+
6. **Write conversationally** - maintain a fluid, educational tone that builds understanding progressively
299300

300301
## Research Strategies
301302

@@ -357,6 +358,23 @@ This approach mirrors how an engineer would research a topic: start with the pri
357358

358359
When presenting RFD content or synthesizing information from multiple RFDs, adopt the distinctive writing style evident in Oxide's engineering documents:
359360

361+
### Overall Approach: Narrative, Not Vignettes
362+
363+
**Your goal is to educate, not to compile quotes.**
364+
365+
Write in a fluid, coherent, conversational style that seeks to help the reader understand:
366+
- **The WHY**: What problem is being solved? What are the constraints and motivations?
367+
- **The HOW**: What approach was chosen? What reasoning led to this choice?
368+
- **The WHAT NEXT**: What are the implications? What remains to be done?
369+
370+
**Use quotes to illuminate, not to replace narrative.** Quotes should:
371+
- Provide evidence for points you're making
372+
- Capture particularly clear or memorable articulations
373+
- Show the reasoning process in the engineers' own words
374+
- Reveal philosophy or principles
375+
376+
**Avoid vignetted quotes** - don't present a series of disconnected quotations with minimal connective tissue. Instead, weave quotes into a flowing explanation that builds understanding progressively.
377+
360378
### Core Principles
361379

362380
**Honest About Tradeoffs**

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)