ElementHelper 2.0

[roryg]

ElementHelper 2 is now up on the 2.0 branch, it's not quite finished yet but you can download a transport package for it here (tested and working on Revo 2.3.1). The code has been completely reworked/refactored and I think is much easier to work with now.

One of the biggest differences feature wise is that elements will now be synced both ways, so if you create an element in the manager a static file will be created for the element and vice versa. (This doesn't work for template variable elements to the template_variables.json file yet.)

There are a number of things still left to do:

1. Template variables need to be saved/removed into/from the template_variables.json file when created/deleted in the manager.
2. Add ability to create MIGx template variables
3. Create tests!
4. Decide if a setting for tv template access is needed.
5. Decide if a setting for auto removing elements is needed.
6. Since elements are synced both ways now there needs to be a way to prevent certain elements from being synced (e.g. a snippet or plugin that's installed with an extra).
7. And probably a bunch of other things I'm forgetting! Feel free to discuss ideas, thoughts etc for 2.0 here.

[DESIGNfromWITHIN]

For me it is not working at fully.... 2.3.1 on localhost...

It is creating categories and if I create a chunk in the manager a file get created, but if I create a file, it does not create a chunk in MODX...

Snippets and plugins are also not created for me..

Template variables are working fine.

I got the following errors on install, might be the issue?

Error 42S22 executing statement: Array ( [0] => 42S22 [1] => 1054 [2] => Unknown column 'modPluginEvent.name' in 'where clause' ) 
INSERT INTO `modx_site_plugin_events` (`pluginid`, `event`, `priority`, `propertyset`) VALUES (:pluginid, :event, :priority, :propertyset) Array ( [/:pluginid\b/] => 1 [/:event\b/] => '' [/:priority\b/] => 0 [/:propertyset\b/] => 0 ) 
Error 23000 executing statement: INSERT INTO `modx_site_plugin_events` (`pluginid`, `event`, `priority`, `propertyset`) VALUES (1, '', 0, 0) Array ( [0] => 23000 [1] => 1062 [2] => Duplicate entry '1-' for key 'PRIMARY' ) 
Error saving vehicle object of class modPluginEvent; criteria: Array ( [name] => ) 
Error 42S22 executing statement: Array ( [0] => 42S22 [1] => 1054 [2] => Unknown column 'modPluginEvent.name' in 'where clause' ) 
INSERT INTO `modx_site_plugin_events` (`pluginid`, `event`, `priority`, `propertyset`) VALUES (:pluginid, :event, :priority, :propertyset) Array ( [/:pluginid\b/] => 1 [/:event\b/] => '' [/:priority\b/] => 0 [/:propertyset\b/] => 0 ) 
Error 23000 executing statement: INSERT INTO `modx_site_plugin_events` (`pluginid`, `event`, `priority`, `propertyset`) VALUES (1, '', 0, 0) Array ( [0] => 23000 [1] => 1062 [2] => Duplicate entry '1-' for key 'PRIMARY' ) 
Error saving vehicle object of class modPluginEvent; criteria: Array ( [name] => ) 
Could not install related objects with locally owned keys for vehicle object of class modPlugin; criteria: Array ( [name] => ElementHelper ) 

[DESIGNfromWITHIN]

UPDATE!

So it does not work with names like this:

chunkname.chunk.tpl
snippetname.snippet.php

This works fine

chunkname.tpl
snippetname.php

[hugopeek]

One thing I'm finding a bit tricky still, is renaming templates.. I want these names to be as clear as possible for clients, so sometimes I change their names to be more descriptive. To do that, you have to disable ElementHelper (to keep ID's the same), change filename to match, and change all template_access references in template_variables.json..

A bit cumbersome. Might it be possible to reference templates by ID for example, and add the name the same way you add a description?

Btw: can confirm that EH works the same as above here on localhost with 2.3.1. Same installation errors too..

[JayCarney]

@hugopeek I'm in the same boat in terms of needing to rename templates for clients, I just don't see a clean way to achieve the behaviour, I think you need to maintain the filename == template_name relationship

[hugopeek]

@JayCarney Thanks. Can imagine how that would be difficult to implement. Will survive without it though ;)

[exside]

@JayCarney & @hugopeek I'm also doing this quite often and never had to disable ElementHelper (at least when I'm the only Admin in the system), ElementHelper just runs for specified user groups (system settings), by default only members of Administrator, so if you need to rename a template, just rename it first in the tree, then rename the file on the server and after that reload the manger page (but don't do it inbetween!), I'm not really using the TV JSON feature, so problems coming from there are not considered in this "workflow". Had a quick scan trough the new code, and would like to say NICE WORK @roryg, looks much cleaner! But did no testing for functionality yet...

[roryg]

@DESIGNfromWITHIN Nice catch, I've just fixed it so you can include dots in element file names now. The install errors are unrelated but will need to be fixed too!

@hugopeek That's a good point, I'll have to think about the best way to achieve that. Adding the ID to a doc comment at the top of the template files might be a possibility but that would mean having something like the following at the top of each template file:

<?php /**
*
* @ID 7
*
*/ ?>

Perhaps that's too much clutter though?

@exside Cheers!

[Qaraqter]

@roryg I wouldn't mind that, but other users might find that to be too much clutter, yes.. Perhaps control this with a system setting?

I also found a little quirk when re-installing on 2.3.1: it didn't set the system events of the plugin (onWebPageInit and onManagerPageInit).

And another question: EH automatically makes all snippets static now too.. Will this be OK when you update the snippets that were installed through package manager? Or are there scenario's imaginable when the old static file would override the updated database entry?

(@Qaraqter = @hugopeek btw ;))

[DESIGNfromWITHIN]

I found a big issue!

When I use the latest version of Element Helper snippets like Wayfinder become static and get comments on top of the file... This actually breaks the functionality!

[roryg]

Thanks @DESIGNfromWITHIN @Qaraqter I've made a note of both issues, I haven't had much time to work on it the past couple of weeks but should be able to sort these bugs out hopefully next weekish.

Just as a word of caution the plugin hasn't been heavily tested yet and is expected to have several bugs so if you're using it with your work beyond just testing it I would advise keeping regular backups! If you'd like it to ignore plugins and snippets you could try changing the respective paths in the settings to a directory that doesn't exist.

[kevinhamil]

@roryg I've just recently switched to a MODx setup and came across EH when searching best workflows... seeing the last discussion was 7 months ago, I was curious to find out if you've had any additional time to further develop this? I have the current version running and I love it, but of course, I am looking forward to a production release. Thanks.

[roryg]

@kevinhamil Yikes time flies! Apologies to all for neglecting this so badly, I'm definitely not abandoning it. I have projects coming up that I'll need ElementHelper for so I will be working on it soon.

[roryg]

Minor update available here - https://db.tt/SBKhONkV

Template Variables will now sync both ways including MIGX tvs. Unfortunately I haven't come up with a good way to sync template variable changes that have been made in the manager yet as Modx doesn't store a timestamp for them, but new TVs made in the manager will be synced to the TV json file.