Skip to content

ASSESSMENT.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
93 lines (70 loc) · 6.91 KB

ASSESSMENT.md

File metadata and controls

93 lines (70 loc) · 6.91 KB

Engineering Assessment — DocuQuery v1.0.0

Date: 2026-03-05 Scope: Full-stack technical audit — security, code quality, testing, infrastructure

This document is an honest self-assessment. It shows what's production-ready, what needs work, and the exact plan to get there. Writing this is part of the engineering process — shipping code you can't audit is shipping code you don't understand.

What's Done Well

Area Evidence
Consistent API contract Every endpoint returns {data, error, meta} — no shape surprises
Async throughout SQLAlchemy async + FastAPI async routes — no blocking on DB or LLM
Type safety Strict mypy (Python), strict TypeScript, zero any types
Auth system JWT access/refresh, bcrypt hashing, protected routes with dependency injection
Clean separation Route handlers are thin; all business logic in services/ — testable, swappable
Structured LLM output JSON mode + Pydantic validation — no brittle regex parsing
Dark mode next-themes + useSyncExternalStore — no hydration flash
Real E2E coverage 10 Playwright tests pass against the deployed app, not just localhost
No dead code Zero console.logs, TODOs, or commented-out blocks

Known Gaps & Planned Fixes

Security (v1.1 Priority)

# Issue Severity Plan
S1 Default SECRET_KEY not validated at startup Critical Add startup assertion — reject boot if key is "change-me-in-production"
S2 Refresh token in localStorage (XSS risk) Critical Move to httpOnly cookie with SameSite=Strict
S3 No rate limiting on auth endpoints High Add slowapi middleware — 5 attempts/minute on login/register
S4 CORS allows methods=["*"], headers=["*"] High Restrict to actual methods (GET, POST, DELETE) and required headers
S5 No CSP headers High Add via Next.js middleware — script-src 'self', style-src 'self' 'unsafe-inline'

Backend (v1.1)

# Issue Plan
B1 No pagination on list endpoints Add limit/offset params with defaults (20/page)
B2 Missing DB indexes on Analysis.resume_id, Analysis.jd_id Add via Alembic migration
B3 Health check doesn't verify DB/LLM connectivity Add /health/ready that pings DB + validates API key
B4 Bare except Exception in parser.py Catch specific exceptions (PyMuPDF errors, UnicodeDecodeError)

Frontend (v1.1)

# Issue Plan
F1 0 frontend unit tests Add vitest suite for hooks, utils, and key components
F2 No error boundaries Add error.tsx in app directory for graceful crash handling
F3 Token refresh race condition Add mutex lock to prevent concurrent refresh attempts
F4 Long page components (125-175 lines) Extract into composition components

Infrastructure (v1.1)

# Issue Plan
I1 No .dockerignore files Add to exclude node_modules/, .venv/, .git/ from images
I2 No type checking in CI Add mypy and tsc --noEmit steps to GitHub Actions
I3 No code coverage enforcement Add pytest --cov with 80% threshold

Production Readiness Checklist

Requirement v1.0 v1.1 (Planned) v2.0
Auth system Done -- --
Input validation Done -- --
Type safety (strict) Done -- --
Backend test suite 59 tests +coverage enforcement --
E2E tests 10 tests +dashboard, comparison --
Frontend unit tests -- vitest suite --
Rate limiting -- slowapi --
Pagination -- all list endpoints --
Error boundaries -- error.tsx --
CSP headers -- Next.js middleware --
Structured logging -- -- JSON logs, correlation IDs
Error tracking -- -- Sentry
Background jobs -- -- Celery/ARQ for LLM calls
Monitoring -- -- Prometheus + Grafana

Summary

DocuQuery v1.0 is a well-structured, fully typed, tested full-stack application with clean architecture and working deployment. The security and scalability gaps are documented, scoped, and have concrete fix plans — not handwaved.

The codebase demonstrates: async Python, structured LLM integration, service layer patterns, modern React (hooks, App Router, server components), comprehensive testing (unit + integration + E2E), and infrastructure automation (Docker, CI, cloud deploy).

What separates this from a tutorial project: it works end-to-end in production, it has real tests that pass against the deployed app, and this assessment exists.