noise support

[paulocoutinhox]

No description provided.

[kaganisildak]

Error raised at private messaging

[03:53:37] [03:53] You: hi
[03:53:43] [03:53] anon3276: Selam
[03:53:44] Peer connected: c484916e3aa6fe0e (anon9532)
[03:53:44] *** anon9532 joined ***
[03:53:53] Received NOISE_IDENTITY_ANNOUNCE from cbed00792f9da82f
[03:53:53] === RECEIVED NOISE IDENTITY ANNOUNCE ===
[03:53:53] From peerId: 'cbed00792f9da82f'
[03:53:53] Preferring to initiate handshake with cbed00792f9da82f (our peerID c484916e3aa6fe0e < their peerID cbed00792f9da82f)
[03:53:53] === INITIATING HANDSHAKE ===
[03:53:53] Remote Peer ID: cbed00792f9da82f
[03:53:53] Creating new initiator session for cbed00792f9da82f
[03:53:53] Calling session->startHandshake()...
[03:53:53] === STARTING NOISE HANDSHAKE ===
[03:53:53] Peer: cbed00792f9da82f, Role: INITIATOR
[03:53:53] === LOCAL STATIC KEY COMPARISON ===
[03:53:53] Local static key (32 bytes): 4888e6d5a26ff9be48ac0100f10efc0285f31b96103d0d5d081d8a6359539766
[03:53:53] Expected from Swift: [COMPARE WITH SWIFT LOG]
[03:53:53] === END KEY COMPARISON ===
[03:53:53] Creating handshake state with pattern: Noise_XX_25519_ChaChaPoly_SHA256
[03:53:53] Role: INITIATOR
[03:53:53] Expected protocol name from Swift: Noise_XX_25519_ChaChaPoly_SHA256
[03:53:53] Expected initial hash from Swift: 4e6f6973655f58585f32353531395f43...
[03:53:53] Handshake state created successfully
[03:53:53] Handshake state pointer: 0x60e0000106c0
[03:53:53] === CHECKING INITIAL HASH STATE ===
[03:53:53] noise_handshakestate_get_handshake_hash returned: 17676 (0x450c)
[03:53:53] Failed to get initial hash: 17676 (Invalid state)
[03:53:53] This is the root cause of the MAC failure!
[03:53:53] === END INITIAL HASH CHECK ===
[03:53:53] Setting local static key...
[03:53:53] Local DH state found, setting private key...
[03:53:53] noise_dhstate_set_keypair_private returned: 0 (0x0)
[03:53:53] Local static key set successfully
[03:53:53] Private key length in DH state: 32
[03:53:53] Initial handshake action: 0 (0x0)
[03:53:53] Starting handshake...
[03:53:53] Handshake started successfully
[03:53:53] Handshake action after start: 16641 (0x4101)
[03:53:53] Initiator: preparing to write first message
[03:53:53] Initiator handshake action before write: 16641 (0x4101)
[03:53:53] Expected action: 16641 (0x4101)
[03:53:53] Initiator: calling writeHandshakeMessage()
[03:53:53] === WRITING HANDSHAKE MESSAGE ===
[03:53:53] Current handshake action: 16641 (0x4101)
[03:53:53] Expected action: 16641 (0x4101)
[03:53:53] === HANDSHAKE STATE DEBUG ===
[03:53:53] Role: INITIATOR
[03:53:53] Protocol: Noise_XX_25519_ChaChaPoly_SHA256
[03:53:53] === HANDSHAKE STEP ANALYSIS ===
[03:53:53] Current handshake step: 0
[03:53:53] Initiator: This is the FIRST message (32 bytes)
[03:53:53] Initiator: Expected: 32 bytes (ephemeral key)
[03:53:53] === END HANDSHAKE STEP ANALYSIS ===
[03:53:53] === END HANDSHAKE STATE DEBUG ===
[03:53:53] Preparing message buffer (1024 bytes)
[03:53:53] Message buffer initialized: data=0x619000030280, size=0, max_size=1024
[03:53:53] ✓ Correct: size=0, max_size=1024 (noise-c will set size after write)
[03:53:53] Preparing payload buffer (empty)
[03:53:53] ✓ No payload buffer provided (testing if nullptr causes AEAD tag)
[03:53:53] Validating parameters before write_message...
[03:53:53] ✓ No payload buffer provided (testing if nullptr causes AEAD tag)
[03:53:53] === FORCE SET LOCAL STATIC KEY ===
[03:53:53] Setting local static key before write_message...
[03:53:53] Local static key size: 32 bytes
[03:53:53] Local static key (first 8 bytes): 4888e6d5a26ff9be
[03:53:53] noise_dhstate_set_keypair_private returned: 0 (0x0)
[03:53:53] ✓ Local static key set successfully before write_message
[03:53:53] === END FORCE SET LOCAL STATIC KEY ===
[03:53:53] All parameters validated, calling noise_handshakestate_write_message...
[03:53:53] ✓ Message buffer: size=0, max_size=1024 (correct for output)
[03:53:53] ✓ No payload buffer (testing if nullptr causes AEAD tag)
[03:53:53] noise_handshakestate_write_message returned: 0 (0x0)
[03:53:53] === BUFFER SIZE DEBUG ===
[03:53:53] After write_message: messageBuffer.size=32, messageBuffer.max_size=1024
[03:53:53] Role: INITIATOR
[03:53:53] Initiator expected: 32 bytes (first XX message)
[03:53:53] === END BUFFER SIZE DEBUG ===
[03:53:53] === MESSAGE RESIZE DEBUG ===
[03:53:53] Before resize: message.size() = 1024
[03:53:53] noise-c wrote: messageBuffer.size = 32 bytes
[03:53:53] noise-c buffer max: messageBuffer.max_size = 1024 bytes
[03:53:53] After resize: message.size() = 32 bytes
[03:53:53] ✓ Message correctly resized to 32 bytes
[03:53:53] === END MESSAGE RESIZE DEBUG ===
[03:53:53] ✓ Message size is correct for role
[03:53:53] Initiator: expected 48 bytes, got 32 bytes
[03:53:53] Initiator generated message of 32 bytes, expected 48 bytes
[03:53:53] === OUTGOING MESSAGE COMPARISON ===
[03:53:53] Handshake message (32 bytes): e294031c9f11af5a13262bda06fd57ede1de4c3df2586c66935421617a744c6b
[03:53:53] Expected from Swift: [COMPARE WITH SWIFT LOG]
[03:53:53] Role: INITIATOR
[03:53:53] === END MESSAGE COMPARISON ===
[03:53:53] Handshake action after write: 16642 (0x4102)
[03:53:53] === FINAL MESSAGE VERIFICATION ===
[03:53:53] Returning message with size: 32 bytes
[03:53:53] First 48 bytes: e294031c9f11af5a13262bda06fd57ede1de4c3df2586c66935421617a744c6b
[03:53:53] === END FINAL MESSAGE VERIFICATION ===
[03:53:53] Handshake step incremented to: 1
[03:53:53] === HANDSHAKE MESSAGE WRITTEN ===
[03:53:53] Handshake initiated successfully with cbed00792f9da82f, data size: 32
[03:53:53] === HANDSHAKE INITIATION COMPLETE ===
[03:53:53] === SENDING NOISE HANDSHAKE INIT ===
[03:53:53] To peerId: 'cbed00792f9da82f'
[03:53:53] Handshake data size: 32 bytes
[03:53:53] Sent Noise handshake init to cbed00792f9da82f
[03:53:53] Received NOISE_HANDSHAKE_RESP from cbed00792f9da82f
[03:53:53] === RECEIVED NOISE_HANDSHAKE_RESP ===
[03:53:53] From peerId: 'cbed00792f9da82f' (size: 16)
[03:53:53] Payload size: 96 bytes
[03:53:53] Local peerId: 'c484916e3aa6fe0e' (size: 16)
[03:53:53] Our role: INITIATOR (localPeerId: 'c484916e3aa6fe0e' vs remotePeerId: 'cbed00792f9da82f')
[03:53:53] === CALLING handleIncomingHandshake ===
[03:53:53] PeerId: 'cbed00792f9da82f'
[03:53:53] Payload size: 96 bytes
[03:53:53] Payload (first 32 bytes): 0b1ca62514a08bcdda0fc705ba510bd44a121f27a1e9a735e4e91c7dbc303a0b
[03:53:53] HandleIncomingHandshake: local='c484916e3aa6fe0e', remote='cbed00792f9da82f'
[03:53:53] === ROLE RESOLUTION COMPARISON ===
[03:53:53] Local PeerID: 'c484916e3aa6fe0e'
[03:53:53] Remote PeerID: 'cbed00792f9da82f'
[03:53:53] Role comparison: 'c484916e3aa6fe0e' < 'cbed00792f9da82f' = true
[03:53:53] Resolved role: INITIATOR
[03:53:53] Expected from Swift: [COMPARE WITH SWIFT LOG]
[03:53:53] === END ROLE RESOLUTION ===
[03:53:53] Message size: 96 bytes, forceReset: false
[03:53:53] === PROCESSING HANDSHAKE MESSAGE ===
[03:53:53] Peer: cbed00792f9da82f, Message size: 96
[03:53:53] Role: INITIATOR
[03:53:53] Protocol: Noise_XX_25519_ChaChaPoly_SHA256
[03:53:53] === INCOMING MESSAGE COMPARISON ===
[03:53:53] Message hex: 0b1ca62514a08bcdda0fc705ba510bd44a121f27a1e9a735e4e91c7dbc303a0bf9f66002585c80333f6e21b8f3adab380ee59fa24cf9751174fe7fca598451f7a43f41824e4e0f30106e65cc0dadde5d29df00750ee24b0be7c693e50f30342c
[03:53:53] Message size: 96 bytes
[03:53:53] Expected from Swift: [COMPARE WITH SWIFT LOG]
[03:53:53] === END MESSAGE COMPARISON ===
[03:53:53] Initiator: processing handshake response (96 bytes)
[03:53:53] Initiator: after this, should generate 64-byte final message
[03:53:53] Using existing handshake state
[03:53:53] Current handshake action: 16642 (0x4102)
[03:53:53] Reading handshake message, size: 96
[03:53:53] Trying to read handshake message: data=0x608000019120, size=96
[03:53:53] Handshake input hex: 0b1ca62514a08bcdda0fc705ba510bd44a121f27a1e9a735e4e91c7dbc303a0bf9f66002585c80333f6e21b8f3adab380ee59fa24cf9751174fe7fca598451f7a43f41824e4e0f30106e65cc0dadde5d29df00750ee24b0be7c693e50f30342c
[03:53:53] === XX PATTERN MESSAGE STRUCTURE ===
[03:53:53] Message size: 96 bytes (expected for XX responder->initiator)
[03:53:53] Ephemeral key (e) - 32 bytes: 0b1ca62514a08bcdda0fc705ba510bd44a121f27a1e9a735e4e91c7dbc303a0b
[03:53:53] Encrypted static key (s) - 48 bytes: f9f66002585c80333f6e21b8f3adab380ee59fa24cf9751174fe7fca598451f7a43f41824e4e0f30106e65cc0dadde5d
[03:53:53] Payload tag - 16 bytes: 29df00750ee24b0be7c693e50f30342c
[03:53:53] === END MESSAGE STRUCTURE ===
[03:53:53] NoiseBuffer for read: data=0x608000019120, size=96, max_size=96
[03:53:53] === BUFFER CONFIGURATION ===
[03:53:53] Message buffer: data=0x608000019120, size=96, max_size=96
[03:53:53] Payload buffer: data=0x611000062ec0, size=0, max_size=256
[03:53:53] Payload data vector size: 256
[03:53:53] === END BUFFER CONFIGURATION ===
[03:53:53] Handshake action before read: 16642 (0x4102)
[03:53:53] Expected action for read: 16642 (0x4102)
[03:53:53] Calling noise_handshakestate_read_message...
[03:53:53] Handshake state: 0x60e0000106c0
[03:53:53] Message buffer: data=0x608000019120, size=96, max_size=96
[03:53:53] Payload buffer: data=0x611000062ec0, size=0, max_size=256
[03:53:53] === BEFORE STATIC KEY DECRYPTION ===
[03:53:53] noise_handshakestate_get_handshake_hash (before decryption) returned: 17676 (0x450c)
[03:53:53] Failed to get hash before decryption: 17676 (Invalid state)
[03:53:53] This explains the MAC failure!
[03:53:53] === STATIC KEY DATA COMPARISON ===
[03:53:53] Static key data to decrypt (48 bytes): f9f66002585c80333f6e21b8f3adab380ee59fa24cf9751174fe7fca598451f7a43f41824e4e0f30106e65cc0dadde5d
[03:53:53] Expected from Swift: b27a49c908e0deafbd1f1a4e57b8f46c33b3f11cec59c5b6e3c985aa228116a4
[03:53:53] Role: INITIATOR
[03:53:53] Message size: 96 bytes
[03:53:53] ✗ Static key data MISMATCH with Swift!
[03:53:53] Expected: b27a49c908e0deafbd1f1a4e57b8f46c33b3f11cec59c5b6e3c985aa228116a4
[03:53:53] Got: f9f66002585c80333f6e21b8f3adab380ee59fa24cf9751174fe7fca598451f7a43f41824e4e0f30106e65cc0dadde5d
[03:53:53] This indicates a handshake state divergence!
[03:53:53] === END STATIC KEY DATA COMPARISON ===
[03:53:53] === ATTEMPTING STATIC KEY DECRYPTION ===
[03:53:53] noise_handshakestate_read_message returned: 17668 (0x4504)
[03:53:53] Failed to read handshake message: 17668 (MAC failure)
[03:53:53] Error details: MAC failure
[03:53:53] === STATIC KEY DECRYPTION FAILED ===
[03:53:53] This is likely a MAC failure due to hash/nonce/key mismatch
[03:53:53] Compare the hash above with the Swift logs
[03:53:53] Handshake failed for cbed00792f9da82f: Failed to read handshake message
[03:53:53] Failed to handle handshake response from cbed00792f9da82f: Failed to read handshake message

[paulocoutinhox]

Yes, im in a war to understand what is wrong when use noise. If you have any knowledge, help me.

[kaganisildak]

im also in a war for python version :/
https://github.com/kaganisildak/bitchat-python/blob/noise/dummy/ble_service.py
this version can send and handle private message but still to buggy and cli side vibed, now im refactoring but maybe the handshake part can help to you

[paulocoutinhox]

Your handshake part is working with noise protocol? I get the source and call iA to understand your noise impl and it sad:

Now I understand the issue! The Python code doesn't use Noise Protocol at all. It uses a simple X25519 key exchange with AES-GCM encryption. The C++ code is trying to implement Noise Protocol handshake, but the Python implementation uses a much simpler approach.

[kaganisildak]

i think i solved dm part now
checkout https://github.com/kaganisildak/bitchat-python

[paulocoutinhox]

it works in part, no message is sent, and after no device is visible and dm message is never received

[kaganisildak]

Today jack release new changes packet format, im working on that